Friction between crypto exchange platforms and enforcement agencies is not news anymore, if we go by the recent statistics of crypto moguls and their businesses facing the wrong side of law. However, when the case pertains to a host country trying to prosecute a high profile foreign national whose country is facing presidential elections, heads are supposed to roll.
This is the synopsis of the ongoing trial of Binance executive and U.S. citizen Tigran Gambaryan versus the state of Nigeria- a legal battle that has potential to turn international relations sour.
Tigran who is serving as Binance’s Head of Financial Crime Compliance was arrested in Nigeria in February this year and is currently facing prosecution over alleged financial irregularities.
U.S is going through an election year and both political spectrums- Democrats and Republicans- are eyeing support from the 50 million strong crypto community in America. The ongoing trial of Tigran has created a pickle of a situation as several U.S. lawmakers accused Nigeria of abducting him and asked president Joe Biden to intervene and demand safe extradition of the Binance executive.
Meanwhile, Nigerian authorities have reiterated that they are following “due process of law” in the case. In this article, we will provide a 360 degree explainer on the ongoing trial of Tigran/Binace versus Nigeria and the geo-political repercussions of it.
Who is Tigran Gambaryan of Binance ?
Tigran Gambaryan is a former federal agent with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) of the U.S. As a federal officer, Gambaryan was involved in an operation where authorities had successfully seized $4.725 Billion in illicit funds. After his prolific career in IRS that lasted for ten years, Gambaryan joined Binance in 2021 as head of financial crime compliance.
What went down in Nigeria ?
According to 16 U.S. lawmakers who petitioned Biden to intervene in the case, Tigran travelled to Nigeria on February 26 this year allegedly at the invitation of the Nigerian government for high-level meetings regarding compliance issues of Binance with local Nigerian laws. As per the family of Tigran and U.S. lawmakers, Tigran took part in two meetings with Nigerian authorities initially after which he was detained by them. Nigeria has charged Tigran and Binance for alleged financial irregularities leading to terror financing and tax evasion. By March 2024, Binance stopped all its operations in Nigeria.
Allegations of Mistreatment
The U.S. lawmakers and family of Tigran have accused Nigerian officials of illegally detaining Tigran and denying him basic prisoner rights. In a letter written to U.S. president Joe Biden, the lawmakers expressed concerns over the manner in which Tigran was treated by Nigerian authorities.
“Mr. Gambaryan’s detainment has been marked by excessive and harsh treatment. Further, he is not permitted to meet with his legal team without the presence of government officials and armed guards. It is crucial to emphasize that the charges against Mr. Gambaryan are baseless and constitute a coercion tactic by the Nigerian government to extort his employer Binance. Following these charges, Mr Gambaryan qualifies as a U.S. citizen wrongfully detained by a foreign government (sic),” read an excerpt from the letter.
What is the Tigran versus Nigeria case?
After Tigran was detained and formally arrested by Nigerian authorities, another senior Binance executive Nadeem Anjarwalla was also taken into custody. Both the officials were charged for financial irregularities and the case has now gone to trial. To understand the trial, it is important to know the genesis behind the ongoing friction between Nigerian authorities and crypto platforms.
The Genesis of Friction b/w Nigeria and Crypto
In 2017, the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) issued a circular warning banks and other financial providers about the danger of cryptocurrencies, stressing that virtual assets are not acceptable as legal tender in Nigeria.
The circular had little to no effect as crypto adoption grew exponentially in Nigeria with Binance becoming the top choice platform for many crypto enthusiasts in the country.
Crackdown Begins
In 2021, the CBN issued regulations foreboding banks and other financial organizations from supporting crypto transactions. The main cause for this stringent action by CBN was the unpredictable volatility of cryptocurrencies and their possible use for illicit purposes.
Following CBN’s blanket ban, the Nigerian Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) also entered the picture in 2023 and declared that Binance was not an authorized entity and cautioned investors away from the platform. It was in the midst of this conundrum that Tigran travelled to Nigeria to negotiate on behalf of Binance.
On March 8, following the arrest of Tigran, Binance announced its decision to halt all Naira services in the country, urging customers at the time to withdraw their NGN balance or it will be automatically converted to Tether stablecoin.
What do Nigerian Officials Say?
Commenting on the situation, the Minister of information and National Orientation, Mohammed Idris said that due process was applied in every stage of the Binance executive trials. Till now, there has not been any official communication between U.S. and Nigeria till now.
Why is Nigeria going after a U.S. citizen?
Nigeria’s political and economic motivations for pursuing the crypto trial against a US person are multifaceted. The Nigerian government claims it is determined to retain control over its financial ecosystem and to exercise its jurisdictional authority against platforms promoting illicit activities. By bringing Tigrin on trial, the Nigerian authorities wish to serve a cautionary tale for the rising crypto community in Nigeria
Political Context of the Binance Executive Trial
As the US presidential election of 2024 draws near, policymakers are realising the growing impact of the bitcoin community. Millions of Americans have poured money into and supported digital assets, making the crypto vote a powerful force.
With promises to encourage innovation, make rules clear, and create a more conducive climate for cryptocurrencies, candidates are now aggressively pursuing supporters of the cryptocurrency space.
International observers have taken note of this change in political attitude, with nations such as Nigeria attentively monitoring the US developments. In an attempt to exercise regulatory authority while conveying a strong message to the global crypto community, Nigerian authorities have turned the contentious crypto trial involving a US citizen into a litmus test.